Philadelphia Flyers fans have clamored for the acquisition of Cherry Hill’s Bobby Ryan since oh I don’t know, his conception? Thursday afternoon, on the eve of the NHL Entry Draft, ESPN’s Pierre LeBrun reported that the Flyers are themselves interested in Ryan
. It’s not the first time we’ve heard it, but it’s worth considering even if it’s somewhat unlikely.
Of course, the Flyers are linked to a handful of big-name players at every major player movement date, and Ryan is just one of a few mentioned in connection to Philadelphia this off-season. Most attention to date has been focused on a pair of defensemen from Nashville, a certain Mr. Nash out of Columbus, and Zach Parise. Each of those four players also have stories attached as to why they are unlikely at best to dress in Orange & Black next season.
But what about Ryan?
Nash is expensive, both in terms of his huge cap hit/contract duration and what Blue Jackets GM Scott Howson will likely require to deal him. Parise will be the most sought after forward in the free agent market by a large margin, and there’s been a report that he’s unlikely to choose a Devils rival. Will the difficult in acquiring one of those two drive up the Ryan market? If so, what would he cost?
The challenge that comes with having high-ceiling young players like Brayden Schenn and Sean Couturier on your roster this time of year is that any trade partner is going to start negotiations by naming one of them. In this case, LeBrun has a source saying any deal for Ryan would need to center around Schenn going the other way.
Coming to Philadelphia along with Wayne Simmonds in exchange for future Stanley Cup Champion Mike Richards, Schenn is a player the Flyers would and should be intensely reluctant to deal. He came over complete with the billing of the best prospect not currently in the NHL, and the Flyers have him locked up for at least the next two seasons, during which he could develop out of potential stud mode into total-stud-right-now mode.
Ryan’s no slouch either, topping 30 goals in his four full seasons (the first being only 64 games). The second overall pick in 2005 checks in at 6’2, 200+, with a cap hit just north of $5M through 2014-2015.
It’s no secret that the Flyers would likely prefer to trade James van Riemsdyk, whose name has fueled most trade rumors lately. But, how likely is it that the Ducks are interested in swapping their big winger from Jersey for another one who has lower production and more injury questions?
Although the speculation winds seem to be at JVR’s back, it’s not exactly the ideal time to trade him. Coming off an injury-shortened season and sitting in rehab vs. surgery limbo, it’s hard to imagine the Flyers getting full value for the former 2nd overall pick. Just last year, JVR was deemed worthy of a sizable extension. This off-season, perhaps this weekend, the Flyers need to decide whether he’s still worth that deal, or they need to convince someone else he is.
In short, if there’s any meat on this rumor bone, it would take more cargo being loaded onto the flight to California than JVR. The Flyers’ 20th overall is a start, but it’d likely require another rostered player such as a mid-pairing defenseman and/or one of the young forwards not named Schenn or Couturier. Can they afford to give up that kind of defenseman, particularly with Matt Carle ready to test free agency?
In all of the discussion focusing on Nash, Parise, and Ryan, there is the reality that scoring was not the Flyers’ biggest issue, not by a long shot. But with no easy answers on the blue line and the goaltending situation locked in place, it appears Paul Holmgren is in pursuit of another lamp-lighter. If Jaromir Jagr leaves and/or JVR is traded, there will be some opportunities for other forwards to get more minutes. But, also the opportunity for the GM to fill the void with a more proven acquisition.
There’s good reason to assume LeBrun is right that the Flyers are interested in Ryan. The hard part is figuring out a deal that would land him without hobbling the current roster.
This all might be too deep a look into a simple “Rumblings” report, but with temperatures in the 90s, why not chat some hockey? After last year’s draft dealings, nothing can be easily dismissed.
Check out LeBrun’s piece
for more Flyers discussion points, including St. Louis’ interest in Carle and why money won’t be the factor that determines whether Jagr is back in Philly next season.
Stay tuned as things could get interesting ahead of tonight’s draft in Pittsburgh…