Skip to content

Waiting Out a Seller’s Christmas in July

Jul 31, 2012, 9:59 AM EDT

We quickly became comfortable rooting for a big-chip buyer on deadline day. Today, we look at who might be leaving Philadelphia.
After spending most of the trade deadlines in our lifetimes wondering which average to above average Phillies might soon end up on a contending team, we’ve enjoyed the past few seasons on the receiving end. More than just the elation of learning that a specific need-filling ballplayer was on his way to PHL, there was the satisfaction of knowing why. The Phillies have recently been a team for which late July was spent preparing for October. In 2012, we’re reminded that’s not always a given. 
The Phillies officially became sellers after a weekend series sweep to the Braves, and despite experience to the contrary, the feeling of watching our guys’ names show up rumored to be headed elsewhere is alien. On the table are regulars and role players who might better fill a need on a team with fewer of them to fill. Some are guys previously bought this time of year, including one who got to ride on a parade float. Others were brought here to get us back. 
By 4 PM today, a WFC or two could be gone. All eyes will be on Ruben Amaro Jr as we wait to evaluate how strongly he can play while holding a losing hand. 
blantonparade.png

Joe Blanton appeared to be the closest to gone on trade deadline eve, but talks had already hit several snags. The Baltimore Orioles are 6.5 games behind the Yankees in the AL East and trying to ward off a close pack in the wild card race. They could use an innings eater, and they set their sights on Blanton. His medicals have already been sent. However, the Phils and O’s reportedly disagree on how much—if any—salary funding will have to come to Baltimore with him. More than just the cash holdup, Amaro is said to want infielder Jonathan Schoop, Baltimore’s third best prospect. Jon Heyman has a source saying the O’s are declining to include Schoop. Even if he was never part of a possible package, you can bet you’ll read and hear that name again every time fans are unhappy with today’s actual returns. 

Blanton’s never been the flashiest player in red pinstripes, but his impact when the Phillies ascended to their glory season in 2008 will never be forgotten. At least I hope not. The Phils weren’t yet a team built on aces, and Blanton is a good reminder of what we thought at the time was a nice deadline pickup and how our expectations have changed since. Who knew we’d be watching him circle the bases in an October game he’d go on to win? You can probably remember exactly where you were when he did. 
victorinoparade.png

Another WFC who might have already played his last game as a Phillie is Shane Victorino

With free agency looming, Vic isn’t having what he hoped would be his contract-year production at the plate. Still, more than a few teams are interested in adding the Gold Glove centerfielder/sparkplug with playoff experience. We’ll talk more about Vic’s tenure as a Phillie if he actually gets dealt, and you can bet it will be a fond sendoff. What kind of return can we hope comes in exchange for the Flyin Hawaiian who once hit a postseason grand slam off of CC Sabathia? The reports have lately been sparse with details, but we’re not expecting to be blown away. Early this morning, it seems the Dodgers are a favorite to land his services if he’s dealt, according to reports by CBS Sports. Seeing him in that uniform would definitely draw a double-take. 
Last year’s trade deadline prize for the Phils was Hunter Pence. We found out he’d be coming to Philadelphia just hours after the Eagles shocked the NFL by acquiring Nnamdi Asomugha. I remember getting texts while at PPL Park for a Union match, then scrolling through twitter and seeing it explode with news that Pence was hugging his Astros teammates in the dugout, saying goodbye after being traded to Philadelphia. One year and one cover of Philadelphia Magazine later, Pence is among those rumored to be on the block today. If so, it is doubtful he’ll fetch a return equalling the package that brought him here, which included Jonathan Singleton and Jarred Cosart. Ruben’s asking price may be prohibitively high though, keeping Pence here at least until the winter market opens. 
Juan Pierre is getting attention as he keeps his batting average floating above .300. At 35, he’ll cost less to acquire and pay for the rest of the season than the other Phillies’ outfielders, though he could still be helpful for a team looking to add a bat at the top of the order. Utility man Ty Wigginton might be as attractive to a contender battling or insuring against multiple injuries as he was to the Phillies in the off-season. 
Cliff Lee appears unlikely to be dealt due to his $25 million annual salary, which when originally signed was labeled by some as Lee “taking less to play in Philly.” Lee can also block a trade to 2/3 of the league (it is uncertain which teams are on the list), further limiting Ruben’s options if indeed he wants to move him. In a losing Phillies season, Lee’s salary is seen by some as an albatross to be shed, if possible, and the deal that previously sent Lee out of town is being remembered more vividly than the one that brought him here just before 2009′s deadline day. Lee originally became a Phillie along with Ben Francisco in exchange for Carlos Carrasco, Jason Donald, Jason Knapp, and Lou Marson. He left town in December 2010 for JC Ramirez, Phillippe Aumont, and Tyson Gillies as the Phillies attempted to restock the cupboard. Both deals are solid examples of how hard it can be to judge talent before it nears MLB readiness. Despite a Lee trade having substantial barriers, part of his career destiny seems to be to change uniforms in a surprise move. If the Phillies are going to make a trade that lands them a valuable haul, he’s the most likely piece to be headed the other way. Ken Rosenthal turned heads by mentioning Lee and other SP’s in the same post as Justin Upton… Phillies Nation digs into the what-if
To date, dealing Major League talent for prospects hasn’t been where Ruben Amaro Jr has made his name. Stocked with more cash than most opposing teams and a division-winning roster bearing few holes, he’s shown his ability to add major pieces other clubs have made available. Prying away valuable prospects won’t be as easy, and who knows if they even pan out. As we wait to hear which if any current Phillies will be shipped off in efforts toward bolstering the 2013-and-beyond rosters, we’re hoping he can find a way to give us a makeshift Christmas in July and maybe even “win” at the table again. This year, it seems like a longshot. 
If not, we just hope he doesn’t cave to a potential buyer’s market and sell for the sake of selling. 

RECENT COMMENTS

wholesale Senior Bow… on ‘Who’s That Guy?…
clubberlangphila on Exit Interviews: Evaluating th…
Renee on Steve Mason will start Game 4…
Renee on At least Evan Turner didn…