Skip to content

You’re Scaring Me, Doc: Halladay Pulled After Two Innings With Shoulder Soreness

May 27, 2012, 2:57 PM EDT

Roy Halladay was removed after two innings of work in Sunday's start against the St. Louis Cardinals, reportedly experiencing right-shoulder soreness.

After surrendering a first-inning grand slam to Yadier Molina, Roy Halladay settled down for a 1-2-3 second. Then Charlie Manuel pinch hit for his two-time Cy Young Award winning pitcher in the top of the third on Sunday.

Officially, Halladay was removed as a precaution, reportedly from experiencing right-shoulder soreness.

Details are sparse, and we don’t want to go overboard with speculation. That said, Halladay’s performances of late are not what we’ve come to expect. Doc’s ERA has doubled over his last six starts, ballooning from 1.95 to 3.98, and he’s been hurt uncharacteristically by the long ball, allowing five home runs in his last 16 innings of work. He gave up one over the previous 54 and a third.

ESPN’s Jayson Stark had this to say in Friday’s Rumblings & Grumblings:

If the Phillies were ranking their top five biggest worries, Roy Halladay probably wouldn’t make the list. Still, after watching him Tuesday
against Washington, one scout said: “I’ve never, ever seen him pitch
like that — not since the Blue Jays sent him back to the minor leagues
[in 2000]. He had no command of his fastball, and he didn’t even want to
use his fastball. I’ve never seen his command that off or his pitch
selection that bad.” In 2010, Halladay averaged 40 fastballs a game. In
his start Tuesday, he threw just 14 all night. People keep speculating
that “something’s up.” But Halladay remains adamant that he’s healthy.

The Phillies lost 8-3 to the Cardinals, dropping Halladay’s record to 4-5 this season.