Skip to content

Union make moves on draft day, scare the hell out of their starting goalkeeper

Jan 16, 2014, 3:52 PM EDT

College soccer is not like football or basketball. Only the nerdiest soccer-heads have seen most of these guys play, so evaluating how a Major League Soccer team does on draft day is damn near impossible.

source: AP

Andre Blake walks on stage after being selected by the Philadelphia Union Thursday.

I’m no expert on that front, so I listen to a few people who are. One of them is Ives Garlacep, who posted his final “Big Board” yesterday before Thursday’s MLS Superdraft (held in Philadelphia).

The Philadelphia Union entered the draft with the No. 2 pick and No. 6 pick in the first round, and two second-round picks. By day’s end, the Union left with three of Garlacep’s top nine players, and (I can only assume) more allocation money they they started with.

They also have a very frightened and/or motivated starting goalkeeper (more in a minute).

The Union sent some allocation money to D.C. United to jump into the No. 1 spot. There they took UConn goalkeeper Andre Blake. The Jamaican international actually joined his national team for a few World Cup qualifiers in 2013 (didn’t play) and, according to all the experts, was far and away the most talented, pro-ready player in the draft. Garlacep had high praise:

“Best talent in the draft. Considered the best goalkeeping prospect in a decade.”

Many fans were confused by two things:

  • Why pay money to jump up a spot when D.C. United made it pretty clear they had no interest in taking Blake? Why not just take him second?
  • Don’t the Union already have a starting goalkeeper in Zac MacMath?

Answer No. 1: It seems that Vancouver was pushing hard to trade into the top spot to take Blake. So D.C. United had leverage, even if it was never going to take Blake.

source:  Answer No. 2 is more complex. Yes, the Union have MacMath, who had a strong season in 2013 after a slowish start. MacMath seemed confused by the pick as well, and apparently let his agent know it at the Convention Center.

But, a few things to remember: It is NEVER a bad draft strategy to simply take the most talented player in the draft, regardless of need. And by all accounts, Blake was far and away the best player in an otherwise “eh” draft class.

source:  Two, Blake is a Generation adidas player. This means the league agreed to terms with him before the draft, and his salary does not count toward the Union’s salary cap. Players “graduate” from the program after a year or two, but it could be longer if Blake doesn’t play right away.

Three, the Union have no backup goalkeeper right now, and MacMath’s play improved last year after the team brought in a proven backup. And, if Blake proves as strong as people say, maybe he earns the job and MacMath is a valuable trade piece.

To move up and get Blake, the Union sent the always ambiguous “allocation money” to D.C. United. In its simplest terms, allocation money is just money going from one team to another, except that it originally came from a league-funded pool of cash. We don’t get to know exactly how much money the Union paid (at least not yet), but the team then turned around and traded down from No. 6 to No. 10, and then from No. 10 to No. 15. In both of those deals, they got allocation money back. I can only assume they either broke even or made a net gain in the wallet.

At No. 15, the team drafted Brazilian Pedro Ribeiro, a huge (6-foot-4) midfielder from Coastal Carolina University. Ribeiro was the No. 6 player on Garlacep’s “Big Board:”

“The tall Brazilian playmaker is impressive on the ball, and can pass as well as anyone in this draft, but conerns about his ability to be a 90-minute player in the pros”

In the second round, the Union filled two big needs by taking midfielder Kevin Cope out of Michigan State and left back Robbie Derschang from Akron.

Also Thursday:

  • Union brass indicated that talks are still ongoing with Maurice Edu, and that the rumor that the league “blocked” the move was untrue. John Hackworth is optimistic, saying to ESPN, “I think something very good is going to come out of it.”
  • The Union claim they were in hard on Michael Bradley, who signed with Toronto.
  • The team announced the signing of Argentine midfielder Cristian Maidana as a designated player, who has spent the last day responding to tweets welcoming him to Philadelphia (he doesn’t speak much, if any, English). It’s a promising move in my opinion, as the team resisted the urge to sign a “name” designated player just to appease people. And at just 26 years old, Maidana is definitely in his “prime.”

The rest of the draft wraps up next Tuesday, and the Union are slated to pick four more times.

  1. philsoc8 - Jan 16, 2014 at 4:08 PM

    The thing about the Blake/MacMath thing is that Hackworth’s right hand man is Rob Vartughian, assistant coach and goalkeeper coach, who coached MacMath at UMaryland and the last few years with the Union.

    He knows that MacMath is an average MLS goalkeeper at best (and that didn’t happen very often last season). I disagree with you when you say he had a “strong” second half of the season. All that happened was that he improved from terrible to ok.

    On the other hand, in a weak draft, Blake is the only no-brainer – a truly elite athlete. His upside is much higher and his salary cap hit will be much lower.

    Great move by the U.

    • lambo - Jan 16, 2014 at 4:19 PM


    • Simmonds17 - Jan 16, 2014 at 4:51 PM

      Let me see if I have this straight. The Union are a team of questionable defensive skill, yet MacMath had one of the highest “clean sheet” or shutout totals last season. I know goalkeepers can’t take full credit for shutouts but if MacMath is so terrible, the other team didn’t seem to find the back of the net all that much. Also, the Union didn’t use either of its backups for a league game last season (or even a U.S. Open Cup match, I believe) which you’d think a team with a bad ‘keeper would do.

      I do not consider myself a soccer expert and based on your screen name, I assume that you do. But I’ve watched the Union long enough to remember Chris Seitz. Now, that was bad goaltending. In a low-scoring sport, I understand that it’s hard to choose among goalkeepers with fairly similar stats, but the guy I watched last year was athletic, active and bounced back well from mistakes.

      I’m open to Blake being a great player for the Union. But you’ll have to convince me MacMath is even a small part of this team’s problems. I consider him, McInerney and Williams the most valuable guys on the team.

      • Broadsthooligans - Jan 17, 2014 at 1:28 AM

        Williams okugo and Parke all appeared or garnered votes on various end of season top 11 teams. Not a great defense but a prett solid one.

  2. TurtleTurtle - Jan 16, 2014 at 4:40 PM

    Has there been any more information on Edu to the Union or was that deal was totally put down by MLS?

    • Steve Moore - Jan 16, 2014 at 5:11 PM

      Hackworth and Sakiewicz today seemed optimistic that it’ll still get done. Personally I take the lack of news as a good sign. Means sides are talking to each other instead of the media.

  3. Tom - Jan 17, 2014 at 10:23 AM

    “College soccer is not like football or basketball.” People actually attend those sports.

    • Lambo - Jan 17, 2014 at 11:52 AM

      More people attend the union than the 6ers so… yeah… there’s that

    • 33 - Jan 17, 2014 at 12:08 PM


  4. 33 - Jan 17, 2014 at 3:02 PM

    MacMath’s agent: “Zac, this is why I told you to delete that tweet.”


(email will not be published)