Skip to content

Chase Utley’s Extension Could Actually Reach Five Years, $75 Million

Aug 8, 2013, 4:03 PM EDT

utley throw

It turns out Chase Utley could be in Philadelphia a lot longer than two years. How does 2018 sound?

Thanks to the unique structure of Utley’s new contract, it could happen. While the extension only guarantees the five-time All Star two more years with the Phillies, if he manages to stay healthy it could go as long as five.

FOX Sports’ Ken Rosenthal has obtained the details behind Utley’s vesting options, revealing a deal that works out almost closer to a football player’s contract. We’ll leave the ‘splaining to the hot-shot reporter on this one:

Utley will receive $15 million guaranteed in 2014 and $10 million in ’15, sources said. He also can earn an additional $5 million in ’15 if he is not on the DL for more than 15 days with specified knee condition. The contract also includes a $2 million buyout and a full no-trade clause.

The formula for Utley’s vesting options is straightforward: He needs to reach 500 plate appearances in 2015 to guarantee himself a $15 million salary in ’16. The same math applies in [’17 and ’18], when Utley will be 39.

If Utley falls short of 500 plate appearances in any of those seasons, his option would revert to a conditional club option, sources said. The value of those options would range from $5 million to $11 million, depending upon how many days he spent on the disabled list the previous season.

The value of those options will depend upon how many days he spent on the disabled list the previous season.

It would take a fairly extended absence – roughly two months – for Utley not to reach 500 plate appearances in a given year, at least as long as he continues batting near the top of the order. While he failed to reach 500 the previous two seasons, he managed to surpass that threshold in 2010, making it to 511 despite playing in just 115 games.

Gotta like that the Phillies still have the option to keep Utley at a discount even in the event injuries prevent him from reaching those goals. If his contract had come up last season, I’m not sure there would have been as much interest in re-signing him. The 34 year old is having quite the bounce-back year after rehabbing those knees though, proving injury was behind his sharp decline in recent years.

Obviously if Utley manages to stay on the field, yet his production drops as he gets older, the deal could eventually turn bad for the Phillies much later on. That combination of events seems somewhat unlikely where we stand today though.

Very interesting structure for a baseball deal, but it seems like a very sensible deal for both sides. Utley gets some assurance he can remain with the club beyond the two years, and the Phils have plenty of outs if it’s no longer working out.

>> Vesting options boost Utley’s deal with Phillies [FOX]

  1. America#1 - Aug 8, 2013 at 4:19 PM

    This is worse than that guy’s Obama slurp comment from the other day.

    • mykhuis - Aug 8, 2013 at 5:04 PM

      The guy was referring to something Papelbon said as a reason for his dislike of Papelbon. Just because it was somewhat political in nature doesn’t mean he (the commenter) “slurps” the president in any way. In any event, I suggest the both of you leave political comments off a sports blog. You’re both entitled to your opinions, but people don’t come here to talk about that stuff. Laying out a political opinion of any stripe is just asking for conflict in a place like this.

  2. mykhuis - Aug 8, 2013 at 5:07 PM

    I’d be surprised if he makes it past three years, but we shall see. Smart of them to give themselves an out just in case. Hopefully Chase will be around to mentor his replacement.

  3. Andy Schreiber - Aug 8, 2013 at 5:59 PM

    I sincerely hope that he makes it through all 5 years. Great to not ever have to see him play for another team during his MLB career.

    Hope he gets to make one more parade speech (although a tad cleaner). :)

    • Vitamin D - Aug 8, 2013 at 7:04 PM

      As much as $15M is potentially a lot to throw at Utley for 2018 (age 39 all season), the way it’s structured actually makes some sense. It makes both sides have some skin in the game – Utley has to keep himself in game shape and give the Phillies at least 3/4 of a quality season if he wants to bank as much money as possible. If that happens, the Phillies should still have one of the best 2B in the game. If he gets hurt and the options don’t vest, the Phillies can still retain his services at a more reasonable price. If he becomes ineffective and winds up as a platoon player, the Phillies can still hold on to him at a reasonable price.

      • Andy Schreiber - Aug 8, 2013 at 7:56 PM

        Exactly. Heck, if Utley is anything like he has been this season, $15 is a bargain. (Not much more than they’re paying Rollins right now for far less production.)

  4. Hiccup - Aug 10, 2013 at 4:35 PM

    $15,000,000! He deserves every penny of it. $7,500,000 per bum knee, should be enough to buy a couple of titon pinions. I watched the clip of his Eorld Series Celebration speech and it did send shivers up my spine but I think more from the roar of the crowd rather than his choice of words. I miss those winning years. Chase said we can do it again into the microphone as he looked into the stands where Rubes sat with the fresh inked contract.

    • willh888 - Aug 10, 2013 at 7:44 PM

      EFC’s yo

      • Hiccup - Aug 12, 2013 at 7:22 AM

        Eolde F&cken Champions!!!

(email will not be published)